, , ,

The Trip that Shattered Malcolm X’s Racial Dogmatism

1964

In the months bridging the spring and summer of 1964, in the heat of the American Civil Rights struggle, Malcolm X would go on a pilgrimage that would profoundly change his political and religious outlook, and most significantly, shatter his racial dogmatism. The paradigm shift that he experienced elevated his status in the eyes of the vast majority of observers and guided him towards the right side of history.

Exile from the Nation of Islam

Malcolm had not long left the Nation of Islam (NOI) and was in a period of intense introspection. The NOI was the movement that he credited with saving him at his lowest point in prison, having been arrested for a series of robberies. It had provided him with a sense of existential direction and had provided him and his family materially. Without the Nation he might have been at risk of impoverishment. The Nation’s co-founder, Elijah Muhammad, had been to Malcolm the father figure that he so craved having lost his own at the hands of white supremacists at the tender age of 6. But as we repeatedly see in the lives of great women and men, not least of which the Prophet Muhammad, these periods of profound loss are usually followed by an elevation in thinking and being.

CONDEMN

Despite having left the NOI, Malcolm would have paid tribute to it’s leader and some of its ideas quite regularly in this transitory period. While it seems that he began questioning the racist ideas of the NOI, namely that all white people are devils, as well as explicit advocacy for complete racial segregation, he had not yet publicly distanced himself from this racism. It was in this period, having lost so much and having to reassess his outlook, Malcolm decided to travel to the Middle East and Africa, a trip that would feature travelling to Mecca to perform the Hajj.

The Hajj

kaba mataf

The Hajj proved to be Malcolm’s initiation into Orthodox Islam and away from racism. Looking back on Malcolm’s life, it is easy to see why the Nation of Islam’s racist ideology could find a home within him. As well as taking his father from him, white supremacists had burnt Malcolm’s family out of their home a number of times forcing the family to move cities. He had been a well-rounded, academically gifted child until the moment his teacher, on hearing that Malcolm wanted to be a lawyer, advised him that this wasn’t a realistic job “for a N****r”. From his early childhood in the 1920’s, through to his later experiences in the 60’s, Malcolm was one of the millions of oppressed African Americans facing crippling and systemic racism at the hands of the state of which he was a (third-class) citizen.

In attending the Hajj, Malcolm was suddenly faced with the powerful beauty that is the multiracial, multi-ethnic and multi-gender mass of pilgrims. It proved to be a paradigm shifting moment for the evolving Malcolm. This was perhaps the first time he was aware of people so evidently flowing in racial harmony. In his diary he wrote,

“Islam brings together in unity all colors and classes…Everyone shares what he has, those who have share with those who have not”.

One of Malcolm’s most prominent biographers, the late Manning Marble, wrote that Malcolm was particularly moved by observing the masses of people on the road to Mount Arafat; crowded, many walking under the Arabian sun, some by camel, others loaded on buses, united, walking harmoniously in one direction, both physically and metaphorically. On seeing the variety of national dresses being worn at the end of the Hajj, Malcolm wrote,

“It is really a beauty to behold. It seems every nation and form of culture on earth is represented here…”.

This experience went beyond merely witnessing racial harmony as an outsider. Malcolm rubbed shoulders with all races as he circumambulated the Kaba. He shared food from the same plate with white and black alike and witnessed a brother and sisterhood that could not be stunted by man-made racial distinctions. He lived the Hajj and the effects were immediate; the postcards Malcolm sent as soon as the Hajj was over showed a definitive movement away from his previously held views on white people as a whole. Writing on some of the white Muslims he seen, he commented that they, “were more genuinely brotherly than anyone else had ever been”.

By no means a ground breaking statement today, but for a man who had not long before been preaching the white devil ideology, a significant break from the past.

Malcolm’s Letter from Mecca

malcolm1

Gary Zimet, Moments in Time

Malcolm’s famous open letter from Mecca further elaborated on the paradigm shift that had occurred during his pilgrimage.

“They were of all colors, from blue-eyed blonds to black-skinned Africans. But we were all participating in the same ritual, displaying a spirit of unity and brotherhood that my experiences in America had lead me to believe could never exist between the white and non-white.”

The powerful spectacle of the Hajj provided the catalyst for Malcolm to shake off his past. Maybe it’s significant that this happened when he was physically (and psychologically) out of the U.S., the venue of racial conflict. Being taken away from the battleground and brought to the otherworldly venue that is Mecca during Hajj might have been crucial to his conversion.

“You may be shocked by these words coming from me. But on this pilgrimage, what I have seen, and experienced, has forced me to rearrange much of my thought-patterns previously held, and to toss aside some of my previous conclusions…during the past eleven days…I have eaten from the same plate, drunk from the same glass, and slept in the same bed—while praying to the same God—with fellow Muslims, whose eyes were the bluest of the blue, whose hair was the blondest of the blond, and who skin was the whitest of the white…we were truly all the same.”

The power of the behavioural ritual is championed by Malcolm’s experiences. Cognitive processes sometimes only go so far. At times there are blocks that need to be dissolved by the power harnessed within an act, a behaviour. Reading the Quranic or Prophetic injunction about equality and the oneness of humanity sometimes is not enough. Experiencing this equality and participating in the acts can prove to be more effective in evoking profound change. This is something that we might at times overlook, in favour of focusing merely on logic or rational explanations. Further to this, at times one part of our being is ahead of another part. It can take our emotions time to catch up with our thoughts and vice-versa. Since leaving the NOI Malcolm had possibly been edging towards renouncing racism. The powerful act of the hajj proved to be the event that brought with it his full transformation into a man committed to promoting racial harmony.

islam

The Oneness of God, the Oneness of Humanity.

Malcolm did what many pilgrims do once they’ve completed the hajj; he took a trip to Medina to visit the grave of the Prophet. While there, on April the 25th 1964, he wrote of the hajj,

“Everyone forgets self and turns to God and out of that submission to the One God comes a brotherhood in which all are equals”.

On Islam as a whole he wrote,

“(the) religion in teaching the Oneness of God, gives the Believer genuine, voluntary obligations towards his fellow man…the True Believer recognizes the Oneness of all Humanity”.

Now take a moment to contrast this universalist, compassionate thinking with his previously held views on the necessity of racial segregation and the status of all white people as being evil. Malcolm had clearly outgrown the maladaptive outlook that he had developed as a reaction to the racism of which he was a victim. By doing so, he had defeated the racists who had directed hate towards him throughout his life.

The Matured Malcolm

Malcolm had arrived to the Hajj as a man who had recently been exiled from his community, a community he had helped build. As painful as this disownment was, the NOI’s loss proved to be Orthodox Islam’s gain; Malcolm was cast out of a community of 100,000 only to be embraced as a brother to the community of over 1,000,000,000. He was turned away from the company of Elijah Muhammad, only to be welcomed into the company of the likes of W.E.B. Du Bois, Maya Angelou (both of whom he met with during the African leg of his trip) and Prince Faisal. He was driven away from the NOI’s archaic racial toxicity only to be guided towards the real Islam’s advocacy of true racial harmony.

One has to be thankful for Malcolm’s trip to Mecca. Had he not been inspired to reevaluate the racism that had been developed in the Nation, he might never have become the icon that he is. His place in the collective consciousness is in large part due to the way in which he evolved with a sincerity that is seldom seen. He renounced past dogmatism in the face of new realisations like a man committed to nothing other than the truth. In his own words,

“Despite my firm convictions, I have always been a man who tries to face facts, and to accept the reality of life as new experience and new knowledge unfolds it.”

truth

Attending the hajj proved to be one of the most significant catalysts in Malcolm’s movement from darkness into light; his hatred of racism was justified but the conclusions which he drew from his experiences were not. As Muslims today will testify to, collective blaming of a whole group is a poisonous position to take.

Where are we?

We have to ask ourselves, would Malcolm have seen the same sister/brotherhood in our cities, businesses, schools and residential areas of today, never mind of the 1960s? Or are the barriers that we overcome in the Hajj, establishing true sister/brotherhood and equality, reinstated once we leave and re-enter the “real” world? Surely, the Hajj is intended to evoke a permanent change, one that would permeate into our societies, germinating rapidly and bringing with it the sweet smell of a truly post-racial society. Just as Malcolm faced up to new realisations and worked towards improving himself in light of them, the hajj should be a time of self-betterment that does not leave us once we have left the Holy City behind. Are we living up to the standard of racial harmony and equality commanded upon us by the One, through his Prophet, with his parting sermon to the faithful,

“Indeed, there is no superiority of an Arab over a non-Arab, nor of a non-Arab over an Arab, nor of a white over a black, nor a black over a white, except by piety.”

Sign up to our mailing list to get stories like this in your inbox.

Like our Facebook page: